Two Ninth Circuit rulings overturn preliminary restrictions on federal crowd-control tactics, affecting protesters, independent journalists and residents of a nearby apartment complex.
PORTLAND, Ore. — November 10, 2026 | WE PNW
A federal appeals court has overturned two preliminary injunctions restricting the use of tear gas, pepper balls and other crowd-control munitions by federal officers outside the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) facility in Portland.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued the rulings Tuesday, November 10, in separate cases brought by protesters and journalists, and by residents living near the facility.
The decisions remove specific temporary restrictions previously imposed by federal district judges in Oregon.
How did the legal disputes begin?
Demonstrations outside the ICE facility in Portland's South Waterfront neighborhood led to repeated confrontations between protesters and federal law enforcement officers.
Protesters and independent journalists argued that federal agents used chemical agents and other munitions against people exercising their First Amendment rights, including individuals who posed no immediate physical threat.
Federal officials maintained that crowd-control measures were necessary to protect personnel, maintain access to the facility and restore order during disruptive demonstrations.
District courts previously granted temporary restrictions while the legal disputes proceeded.
What did the appeals court decide?
In Dickinson v. Trump, the Ninth Circuit vacated the preliminary injunction limiting the use of nonlethal crowd-control weapons.
The majority concluded that officers may use nonlethal force to disperse crowds and restore order under appropriate circumstances without waiting for an imminent threat of physical harm.
The panel also found that the plaintiffs had not established a sufficient likelihood of success on their claim that federal agents deliberately retaliated against them for engaging in First Amendment activity.
The court additionally vacated the provisional class certification covering protesters and journalists.
What about nearby residents?
A separate ruling addressed residents of Gray's Landing, an affordable housing complex near the ICE facility.
Residents reported that chemical munitions entered their apartments and common areas during demonstrations, affecting their health and daily lives.
A district court had imposed temporary restrictions intended to prevent chemical agents from reaching the residential community.
The Ninth Circuit overturned those restrictions.
Democracy Forward, which represents the residents, expressed disappointment and emphasized the continued concerns of families living near the facility.
Not every judge agreed
Circuit Judge Ana de Alba dissented in part.
In the protesters' case, she would have preserved a restriction against firing munitions at a person's head, neck or torso unless the use of deadly force would be legally justified.
Her disagreement highlights the continuing debate over the legal boundaries of federal crowd-control tactics.
What does this mean for Portland?
The rulings remove the particular preliminary injunctions imposed by Oregon federal judges.
They do not give federal officers unlimited authority to use force or eliminate other applicable constitutional and legal protections.
Nor do they resolve every underlying claim arising from the demonstrations.
For Portland, the decisions have implications extending beyond immigration enforcement. They touch on the rights of protesters, the ability of journalists to cover demonstrations and the safety of people living near federal facilities.
WE PNW will continue monitoring the litigation and its implications for Portland residents.
Photo: Archive image, October 4, 2025. Federal officers outside the Portland ICE facility amid CS gas deployed to disperse protesters. Credit: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement / Wikimedia Commons, U.S. public domain.
